Navigating Test-Optional Admissions: Your Guide to Test Score Choices
By Sarah H on Updated:
Test-optional. You hear colleges say it all the time now. It means you don’t HAVE to send your SAT or ACT scores to apply. Sounds simple, right? Nope!
Test-optional has made college admission way more confusing for students. Should YOU send your scores? Or should you go test-free? What’s the smart move to get into college? It’s not the same for every student.
Let’s break down test-optional admissions. Let’s help YOU decide what’s right for YOUR college applications.
Test-Optional: College Admission Just Got More Confusing?
Before, it was simple. Take the SAT or ACT. Get the best score you can. Send it to colleges. Now? Colleges say “Test-Optional.” It’s a CHOICE. And choices can be hard. Do you send scores if you don’t have to? Will it hurt you if you don’t send them? Will it help you if you do? So many questions!
Test-optional is meant to be more fair for students. But it can feel like a puzzle to figure out what to do. Don’t worry! We’re here to help you solve that puzzle and make the best choice for YOU.
Find Your Best-Fit College
Explore your options and find the campus that’s right for you.
What “Test-Optional” REALLY Means – It’s Your Call
Let’s get super clear on what “test-optional” actually means. It means: sending SAT or ACT scores is OPTIONAL. It’s up to YOU. Colleges that are test-optional will look at your application the same way, whether you send scores or not. They say they won’t put students who don’t send scores at a disadvantage.
Test-optional means you get to CHOOSE. You get to decide if showing your scores will help your application – or not. It’s about putting YOU in control.
Why Colleges Went Test-Optional – It’s Not Just COVID
Why did so many colleges go test-optional? Was it just because of COVID? COVID did play a part. It made it harder for students to take tests. But test-optional was a trend even BEFORE COVID. Colleges went test-optional for reasons like:
- Fairness for All Students: Some students don’t test well, even if they are smart and good students. Test-optional is meant to make it fairer for students who shine in class but not on tests.
- Focus on the “Whole Student”: Colleges say they want to see the “whole student,” not just test scores. Test-optional lets them focus more on essays, activities, and who you are as a person, not just a test number.
- Get More Diverse Students: Some think test scores can hurt diversity. Test-optional is seen as a way to get a wider mix of students from different backgrounds.
So, test-optional is not just a quick change. It’s a bigger shift in how colleges are looking at students.
The Big Question: Should YOU Send Your Scores? Let’s Break It Down
Okay, the big question: Should YOU send your SAT or ACT scores? It’s not a yes/no answer for everyone. It depends on YOU and YOUR scores. Let’s break it down into some simple scenarios to help you decide.
Showcase Everything You’ve Achieved
Build a free Cirkled In portfolio that shows who you are beyond test scores.
Scenario #1: Your Scores Are STRONG – Time to Show Them Off!
First, the easy case: Your scores are STRONG. What does “strong” mean? It means your scores are AT or ABOVE the average score for students who get into that college. How do you find that out? Check the college website. Look for their “freshman profile” or “admitted student data.” It will often show the average SAT or ACT score range for students they accept. If your scores are in that range, or even better, ABOVE it? Then YES, send your scores! Strong scores are a plus.
They can help you stand out. They show you can do well on tough tests. In this case, test-optional is a bonus – you get to CHOOSE to show off your good scores!
Pro Tip: Go to Cirkled In’s College Search Page and you’ll get all colleges’ info at one place!
Scenario #2: Your Scores Are “Just Okay” – Think Carefully
What if your scores are “just okay”? What does “just okay” mean? It means your scores are CLOSE to the average score for that college – maybe a little below, maybe right in the middle of the range. This is a trickier choice. Think carefully:
- Look at the “Whole You” App: How strong are the OTHER parts of your application? Are your grades super high? Are your essays amazing? Do you have killer activities? If other parts of your app are super strong, maybe you can go test-optional. Your app might still shine without scores.
- See if Your Scores Show YOU “Get” That College: Think about the college itself. Is it known as a super-test-focused, high-score kind of place? Or is it more about “whole student” stuff? If it’s a test-focused school, sending even “okay” scores might help a bit to show you’re in the ballpark. If it’s more “holistic,” maybe scores matter less, and you can go test-optional.
- When in Doubt? Maybe Send Them: If you are really not sure, and your scores are close to the average, it might be safer to send them. “Okay” scores won’t hurt you, and they might help a little. But again, it depends on your whole application.
Scenario #3: Your Scores Are Low – Test-Optional is Your Friend
Now, the clear case for “test-optional”: Your scores are lower than the average for that college. “Lower” means your scores are BELOW the average range for accepted students. In this case, the test-optional is YOUR FRIEND. It’s there to help students like you! If your scores are lower than the college’s average, then YES, go test-optional. Do NOT send your scores. Why?
Because lower scores won’t help you. They might even hurt your chances a little bit. Test-optional lets you take scores out of the picture and focus on the stronger parts of your application – your grades, essays, activities, and YOU as a person.
It’s Not Just About Scores – Other Things Matter Even More Now
Test-optional means colleges are looking at OTHER things more closely now. If you go test-optional, make sure the REST of your application is AMAZING. Really focus on:
- Your Grades – They REALLY Count Now: If you don’t send test scores, your grades become even more important. Make sure your grades are as high as you can get them. Colleges will look at your grades extra closely if they don’t see test scores.
- Your Essays – Make Them Killer: Essays are always important. But in a test-optional world, they are HUGE. Your essays are your best way to show colleges who you are, what you care about, and why they should pick YOU. Spend extra time making your essays amazing.
- Your Activities – Show What You DO: Colleges want to see what you do outside of class. Your activities, your clubs, your volunteering – these show your passions and skills. Make sure your activities list is strong and shows you are active and engaged.
Action Plan: Make YOUR Test-Score Choice with Confidence!
Ready to decide if YOU should send test scores or go test-optional? Yes! Do these things now to make your smart choice:
- Check Cirkled In for Your Colleges: Use Cirkled In to look up the test-optional policies and score ranges for colleges you are applying to. Get the facts for each school.
- Be Honest About YOUR Scores: Be real with yourself about your scores. Are they strong? Okay? Or lower than average for your target colleges?
- Think “Whole App” Too: Don’t just think about scores. Think about the rest of your application. Are your grades and essays super strong? Or do you need your scores to boost your app?
- Talk to Your Counselor: Still not sure? Talk to your school counselor. They can give you advice just for YOU based on your scores and your college list.
Final Thought: Your Choice, Your Best Application – Test Scores or Not
Test-optional puts YOU in charge. It’s your choice if you send scores or not. Use this guide to think smart. Be honest about your scores and your whole application. And make the choice that makes YOUR application the strongest it can be – test scores or not!
Need more tips on college applications, scholarships, or just how to survive this whole process? Cirkled In has your back—check out Cirkled In resources to help you through every step of your college journey!
$2,500 No-Sweat Scholarship
Real students win our $2,500 scholarship every quarter — yours could be next.